Whether you’re throwing a full-blown costume party or just greeting trick-or-treaters, a themed beverage adds instant fun. The ideas below skip the booze yet keep all the color, flavor, and spooky flair. Each one can be mixed with ingredients found at most supermarkets, so no magic spell is required. Grab your cauldron (or pitcher) and start stirring.
Contents
- 1. Black Cat Cherry Cola Float
- 2. Jack-O’-Lantern Orange Fizz
- 3. Blood Moon Pomegranate Spritzer
- 4. Pumpkin Patch Smoothie
- 5. Candy Corn Layered Milkshake
- 6. Enchanted Forest Green Apple Cooler
- 7. Haunted Honey Hot Cider
- 8. Ghostly White Chocolate Cocoa
- 9. Graveyard Mudslide Shake
- 10. Hocus Pocus Hibiscus Iced Tea
- 11. Caramel Apple Butter Brew
- 12. Creepy Crawly Blueberry Lemonade
- 13. Midnight Blackberry Fizz
- 14. Spiced Maple Bat Latte
- 15. Toxic Slime Limeade
- 16. Monster Mash Melon Cooler
- 17. Harvest Moon Cranberry Sparkler
- 18. Cauldron Bubble Root Beer Float
- 19. Phantom Pineapple Ginger Pop
- 20. Shadow Realm Raspberry Iced Tea
- 21. Orchard Fog Pear Cider
- 22. Bewitched Black Sesame Shake
- 23. Lantern Light Mango Lassi
- 24. Full Moon Cookies-and-Cream Frappé
- 25. Eerie Earl Grey Lemon Spritz
- 26. Spiderweb Salted Caramel Mocha
- 27. Ghoulish Grape Sparkle Soda
- 28. Dark Forest Matcha Latte
- 29. Spellbound Strawberry Basil Agua Fresca
- 30. Specter Citrus Sunrise
- 31. Crypt Keeper Cocoa-Chili Sipper
- 32. Moonlit Mojito Mocktail
- 33. Scarecrow’s Sweet Potato Latte
- 34. Nightmare Nectarine Iced Tea
- 35. Blizzard Bone-Chilling Vanilla Frappe
- 36. Poltergeist Passion Fruit Punch
- 37. Bewitched Blue Lagoon Cooler
- 38. Raven’s Roast Cold Brew Tonic
- 39. Pumpkin King Horchata
- 40. Witching Hour Watermelon Slush
- 41. Gargoyle Grapefruit Cooler
- 42. Monster-Eye Matcha Lemonade
- 43. Spooky Sour Cherry Shrub
- 44. Twilight Tangerine Sparkler
- 45. Silent Swamp Cucumber Mint Cooler
1. Black Cat Cherry Cola Float

Dark cherry cola sets the midnight tone, while creamy vanilla ice cream forms a ghost-white head. The fizz creeps up the sides, creating a frothy, dramatic look that kids love. For extra zing, add a splash of tart cherry juice before dropping in the ice cream. Serve immediately so the float retains its spooky swirls.
2. Jack-O’-Lantern Orange Fizz

Combine sparkling orange soda with a squeeze of fresh orange juice for layered citrus flavor. A quick stir introduces lively bubbles that dance like candlelight inside a carved pumpkin. Garnish with an orange slice trimmed into a jagged “mouth” for playful presentation. It’s simple, vibrant, and refreshingly sweet.
3. Blood Moon Pomegranate Spritzer

Pomegranate juice supplies a rich crimson hue that looks eerie under dim lighting. Top it with chilled seltzer for a bubbly finish and lighter body. A squeeze of lime cuts the sweetness and brightens the flavor. Chill everything ahead of time so the drink stays icy cold without watering down.
4. Pumpkin Patch Smoothie

Pumpkin purée, banana, and vanilla yogurt blend into a velvety sip that feels like pie through a straw. A touch of maple syrup sweetens naturally while pumpkin-pie spice rounds out the flavor. Serve it chilled and finish with whipped cream dusted in cinnamon “soil.” This one doubles as breakfast on crisp October mornings.
5. Candy Corn Layered Milkshake

Start with a vanilla base, divide it, and tint two portions with orange and yellow natural food colorings. Layer from heaviest (yellow) to lightest (white) for that unmistakable tri-color effect. The result mirrors the classic Halloween candy without overwhelming sweetness. Sip through a wide straw to enjoy all layers at once.
6. Enchanted Forest Green Apple Cooler

Tart green apple juice meets a splash of white grape juice for gentle balance. Crushed ice whispers of early autumn frost while a rosemary sprig adds a woodsy aroma. Stir gently to release fragrant oils without bruising the herbs. The crisp, clean profile keeps palates refreshed between candy courses.
7. Haunted Honey Hot Cider

Slowly warm fresh apple cider with whole cinnamon sticks, cloves, and a hint of nutmeg. Just before serving, swirl in local honey for floral sweetness that lingers. The spices perfume the room, delivering instant haunted-house ambiance. Ladle into heat-safe mugs and serve piping hot.
8. Ghostly White Chocolate Cocoa

Melt premium white chocolate into steamed milk for a silky, snow-white base. Vanilla keeps the flavor round and comforting rather than cloying. Float large marshmallows decorated with mini chocolate eyes so they resemble friendly spirits. The drink glows under black-light, adding an extra fun factor.
9. Graveyard Mudslide Shake

Blend chocolate ice cream, milk, and a spoonful of chocolate syrup for ultimate richness. Crushed sandwich cookies mimic fresh cemetery soil on the surface. A cookie “headstone” finishes the graveyard look—and is tasty to boot. Keep spoons handy; this shake is thick enough to require digging.
10. Hocus Pocus Hibiscus Iced Tea

Dried hibiscus petals steep into a brilliant crimson tea bursting with natural tartness. Sweeten lightly with agave syrup to balance the zing. The color alone feels magical under candlelight. Garnish with a lime wheel for an herbal-citrus aroma.
11. Caramel Apple Butter Brew

Whisk apple butter into warm milk until completely dissolved, then sweeten with buttery caramel sauce. Froth the mixture for a silky cap that clings to the mug. A final drizzle of caramel delivers extra decadence. Sip slowly while swapping ghost stories.
12. Creepy Crawly Blueberry Lemonade

Blend fresh blueberries with lemonade concentrate to achieve a spooky sapphire hue. Strain for smoothness, then pour over mountains of ice. A few gummy worms create instant kid appeal and Halloween vibes. Stir just before drinking to keep flavors evenly distributed.
13. Midnight Blackberry Fizz

Simmer blackberries with sugar and lemon zest for a quick syrup, then strain and chill. Combine with club soda to produce tiny purple bubbles that fade into deepest night. A skewer of fresh berries offers a textural contrast. It’s tart, slightly sweet, and wonderfully moody.
14. Spiced Maple Bat Latte

Steam milk with a dash of maple syrup and pumpkin-pie spice, then pour over strong brewed coffee. The maple’s earthy sweetness pairs beautifully with warming spices. A quick cocoa-powder stencil forms a bat silhouette on the foam. Enjoy as a morning pick-me-up before carving pumpkins.
15. Toxic Slime Limeade

Bright limeade gets its glow from fresh juice plus a hint of kiwi purée. A green rock candy stick doubles as both stirrer and sweetener. Crushed ice keeps the temperature frigid, evoking laboratory experiments gone wrong. Kids adore the vivid color and zippy flavor.
16. Monster Mash Melon Cooler

Puréed honeydew mixes with coconut water for subtle sweetness and extra hydration. Scoop melon balls and freeze them so they stand in for chilling “eyeballs.” A squeeze of lime brings everything into focus. Serve in clear cups so the floating orbs remain visible.
17. Harvest Moon Cranberry Sparkler

Cranberry juice and sparkling apple cider join forces in a balanced sweet-tart duo. Bubbles catch the candlelight, resembling stars on a clear fall night. Whole cranberries add a pop of color and help keep ice cubes from clinking loudly. Serve chilled to highlight the crisp flavors.
18. Cauldron Bubble Root Beer Float

Old-fashioned root beer meets vanilla ice cream for an instant creamy foam explosion. A small chunk of food-safe dry ice placed next to the mug—not inside—creates eerie vapor trails. Keep tongs handy for safe handling. The classic flavor combo suits every age.
19. Phantom Pineapple Ginger Pop

Shake chilled pineapple juice with homemade ginger syrup for a tropical-spicy backbone. Top with sparkling mineral water so bubbles lift fragrant notes. A piece of candied ginger offers a sweet-hot chew between sips. The drink’s sunshine color provides a bright break from darker Halloween hues.
20. Shadow Realm Raspberry Iced Tea

Fresh-brewed black tea gains depth from muddled raspberries stirred in while still warm. After straining and chilling, the tea turns a dramatic deep red. A mint sprig cuts through the berry richness with cool fragrance. It’s refined enough for adults yet sweet enough for little vampires.
21. Orchard Fog Pear Cider

Simmer pear juice with cinnamon and star anise for delicate spice. Unlike apple cider, pear offers floral notes and a lighter body. Strain and ladle into heat-proof mugs just as the aroma peaks. It’s gentle enough for children yet sophisticated enough for grown-ups.
22. Bewitched Black Sesame Shake

Toasted black sesame paste blends with vanilla ice cream and milk, delivering a nutty richness and striking color. The shade skirts the line between deep gray and midnight, perfect for a witchy vibe. Whipped cream provides contrast while extra seeds add crunch. Offer small servings—this shake is intense.
23. Lantern Light Mango Lassi

Sweet mango pulp puréed with yogurt yields a velvety, lantern-like glow. A dash of cardamom delivers warmth fitting for autumn evenings. Serve well-chilled so the flavors stay vibrant, not cloying. It’s a refreshing break after piles of sugary candy.
24. Full Moon Cookies-and-Cream Frappé

Crushed chocolate cookies whir with milk, vanilla, and ice for a thick, spoonable treat. Whipped cream mounds on top like a glowing full moon. Garnish with a round cookie for both flair and extra crunch. Slurp through a wide straw or dive in with a spoon.
25. Eerie Earl Grey Lemon Spritz

Cold-brew Earl Grey tea highlights fragrant bergamot without bitterness. Top with sparkling lemonade for gentle fizz and citrus tang. The result is refined yet festive, a mocktail even tea lovers applaud. Serve over a single large cube to keep dilution minimal.
26. Spiderweb Salted Caramel Mocha

Blend hot cocoa with a shot of brewed coffee and stir in salted caramel sauce. Foam milk separately, then pipe circles of caramel and drag a toothpick outward to create a web. A chocolate chip can play the role of an eight-legged visitor. The sweet-salty profile feels indulgent yet comforting.
27. Ghoulish Grape Sparkle Soda

Mix 100% concord grape juice with sparkling water for a naturally vivid hue. Freeze extra grapes to use as fruit “ice cubes” that won’t water down the drink. The combination is sweet but still refreshing. Kids love the bold color, while adults appreciate the real juice flavor.
28. Dark Forest Matcha Latte

Whisk ceremonial-grade matcha with hot water until frothy, then top with steamed milk of choice. A quick dusting of cocoa through a tree-shaped stencil conjures an eerie woodland scene. Slight vegetal notes of matcha mingle with the chocolate aroma. Best enjoyed warm on a chilly night.
29. Spellbound Strawberry Basil Agua Fresca

Purée ripe strawberries with cold water and a spoonful of sugar, then strain for a silky base. Fresh basil leaves steep briefly, lending herbal intrigue without turning the drink green. Serve over ice so flavors remain bright. It pairs nicely with savory snacks during movie marathons.
30. Specter Citrus Sunrise

Pour chilled orange juice over ice, then slowly float a splash of grenadine so it sinks, creating a glowing gradient. The result looks like dawn breaking over a haunted horizon. A lemon wheel or maraschino cherry adds extra color. Stir just before drinking for an even flavor blend.
31. Crypt Keeper Cocoa-Chili Sipper

Rich dark cocoa mixes with milk and a pinch of warming chili powder for subtle heat. The spicy note sneaks up after each sweet sip, making it memorable. Top with lightly whipped cream to mellow the kick. It’s a crowd-pleaser for anyone craving something beyond standard cocoa.
32. Moonlit Mojito Mocktail

Gently muddle fresh mint and lime wedges with a spoonful of sugar, then top with club soda. The drink stays crystal-clear, catching moonlight like liquid silver. A few mint leaves rise and fall with the bubbles, adding freshness in every sip. It’s crisp, light, and endlessly sippable.
33. Scarecrow’s Sweet Potato Latte

Baked sweet potato purée blends smoothly into steamed milk, offering natural sweetness and color. Brown sugar and a dash of nutmeg enhance its pie-like quality. Espresso is optional; it tastes great with or without. Serve hot and watch the comforting aromas fill the room.
34. Nightmare Nectarine Iced Tea

Cold-brew black tea overnight with sliced nectarines for fruity complexity. The stone fruit adds honeyed notes that soften tea tannins. Pour over ice and garnish with an additional slice for a pop of color. It’s a refreshing alternative to sugary sodas.
35. Blizzard Bone-Chilling Vanilla Frappe

Vanilla ice cream, milk, and a dash of clear peppermint extract whirr into an arctic blast. The light mint note transforms regular vanilla into a chilling treat. Whipped cream peaks like snowdrifts on top. Perfect for those who want a frosty contrast to warm autumn desserts.
36. Poltergeist Passion Fruit Punch

Tangy passion fruit nectar combines with orange juice and lemon-lime soda for sweet-sour balance. Mint leaves float like drifting spirits across the surface. The punch’s tropical aroma livens up even the darkest haunted house décor. Keep extra ice on hand; it tends to disappear quickly.
37. Bewitched Blue Lagoon Cooler

Blueberry purée, lemonade, and a whisper of coconut water yield a dreamy turquoise color. Strain well for a smooth texture that won’t clog straws. Crushed ice amplifies the beachy vibe despite autumn weather. The balance of tart and sweet makes it a house favorite.
38. Raven’s Roast Cold Brew Tonic

Cold brew coffee meets quinine-laced tonic for a sophisticated, bittersweet sip. The two liquids layer beautifully, echoing a raven’s glossy feathers. An orange twist brightens the aroma and softens the bitterness. Stir lightly before drinking to unify flavors.
39. Pumpkin King Horchata

Classic rice-milk horchata gets an October twist with pumpkin purée and pumpkin-pie spice. The result is creamy, comforting, and warmly spiced. A quick shake before serving keeps the cinnamon suspended. It pairs beautifully with churros or cinnamon-sugar donuts.
40. Witching Hour Watermelon Slush

Freeze cubed watermelon, then blend with lime juice and a touch of agave for a naturally sweet slushie. The deep red color pops against black party décor. A squeeze of fresh lime balances the melon’s sugar. Serve immediately to maintain the perfect frozen texture.
41. Gargoyle Grapefruit Cooler

Fresh ruby-red grapefruit juice diluted with sparkling water offers crisp bitterness and refreshing bubbles. A rim of black lava salt intensifies both flavor and Halloween aesthetics. Slight sweetness from simple syrup tempers the tartness. It’s a grown-up option that still fits the theme.
42. Monster-Eye Matcha Lemonade

Shake matcha powder with lemonade for an energizing twist on classic lemonade. A lychee “eyeball” holding a blueberry pupil drifts ominously on top. The drink is equal parts earthy, tart, and lightly sweet. Stir just before sipping to integrate the matcha fully.
43. Spooky Sour Cherry Shrub

Tart cherry shrub made from fruit, sugar, and apple cider vinegar lends depth and zing. Top with chilled seltzer for gentle effervescence and a bracing finish. The vinegar backbone cuts through candy overload. Garnish with skewered cherries for a double dose of flavor.
44. Twilight Tangerine Sparkler

Fresh-pressed tangerine juice lights up the glass with sunset color. A dash of edible shimmer dust creates a galaxy effect as bubbles rise. Top with sparkling water to keep sugars in check. The citrus aroma is a welcome palate cleanser after savory snacks.
45. Silent Swamp Cucumber Mint Cooler

Blend peeled cucumber with water and strain for a light, refreshing base. Fresh mint leaves steep briefly, then the drink is chilled over ice. A squeeze of lemon brightens the vegetal notes while keeping sweetness minimal. Ideal for guests who prefer something less sugary late in the evening.
Nathaniel Lee is an avid cook, drawing on his decades of home cooking and fine dining experience. He is a contributing chef at Mashed, and his recipes and contributions have been featured in Tasting Table, Edible Arrangements, Insanely Good Recipes, and The Daily Meal.
